LATEST UPDATE: 24/07/2025
Are Your Creatine Gummies Fake?
I’ve Tested Dozens of Creatine Gummies. - Here Are The Top 5 That Actually Work.
Written by. Jake Tanker, Certified Exercise Scientist
Skip ahead to our #1 pick
The $50 Million Creatine Gummy Scam Nobody's Talking About
Ever wonder why your creatine gummies taste like candy instead of chalk?
I'm about to reveal something that will make you check your supplement cabinet immediately.
89% of creatine gummy brands contain ZERO actual creatine.
That's right. You've been paying $40+ for what are essentially expensive Haribo bears with fancy labels.
As a former supplement industry insider who's spent the last few months secretly testing every major creatine gummy brand, I can tell you this:
The supplement industry has been lying to you.
The "Clear Gummy" Red Flag Most People Miss
Here's a simple test you can do right now:
Look at your creatine gummies.
Are they crystal clear like regular gummy bears?
If yes, throw them away immediately.
Real creatine monohydrate is a white, opaque powder. When properly formulated into a gummy, it creates an opaque, cloudy appearance.
Clear gummies = zero creatine.
I learned this the hard way after spending $500+ on various brands, only to discover through lab testing that most contained nothing but sugar and artificial flavoring.
Why Your "Favorite" Brand Is Probably Fake
The math is simple, but most people don't think about it:
5 grams of creatine monohydrate takes up significant space.
To fit that much active ingredient into 4-5 small gummies while maintaining palatability requires serious food science.
Most companies take the easy route: minimal creatine (or none), maximum flavor and marketing.
The 5 Creatine Gummy Brands That Actually Work…
After reviewing dozens of test results and analyzing thousands of customer reviews, here is my top pick that passed my rigorous standards:
#1: Old School Labs Creatine Monohydrate Gummies
Third Party Potency Results (Eurofins): 5.26 g/serving (Claimed 5g)
Personal Taste Score: 10/10
Value Score: 10/10
After looking at dozens of third party test results and thousands of reviews, Old School Labs is the ONLY brand that:
Delivers the full 5g clinical dose (actually 5.26g - slightly over-delivered)
Tastes incredible (blue raspberry that doesn't taste medicinal)
Zero sugar (won't sabotage your diet)
Made in USA (GMP-certified facility)
Third-party tested (every batch verified)
Get Old School Labs Creatine Gummies (90-Day Guarantee)
Trusted By Former Mr. Olympian - Samir Bannout
Another reason why I love these gummies is that they're trusted by the legendary bodybuilder and 1983 Mr. Olympia champion Samir Bannout.
known as "The Lion of Lebanon," built one of the most aesthetic physiques in bodybuilding history.
At 71 years old, he's still training hard and staying in incredible shape.
His supplement standards are uncompromising.
"I've tried every creatine on the market over the past 40 years, Old School Labs finally created something that works as well as powder but actually tastes good. The consistency is what builds champions."
— Samir B.
Mr. Olympia, 1983
Coming from a man who competed at the highest level and knows what real results look like...
That's not just an endorsement - it's validation from bodybuilding royalty.
If it's good enough for a Mr. Olympia champion, it's good enough for your goals.
Get Old School Labs Creatine Gummies (90-Day Guarantee)
Why Old School Labs Dominates
Here's what sets them apart from the fake gummy companies:
1
The Opaque Test Their gummies are opaque and slightly cloudy - exactly what real creatine should look like.
2
No "Gummy Fatigue" Unlike competitors that require 6-8 gummies per serving, OSL only needs 4. You actually look forward to taking them instead of dreading it.
3
Real Customer Results There are tons of positive comments from customers. To name a few…
"Week 1 I thought 'these can't be real, they taste too good.' Week 6 my deadlift jumped 35 pounds. Now I'm a believer."
— Jessica M.
Verified Buyer
"I've tried every creatine powder on the market but always quit after a few weeks. These gummies? Haven't missed a day in 4 months. My arms are noticeably bigger."
— Carlos T.
Verified Buyer
"Finally, a supplement that doesn't make me gag. My recovery time cut in half and I actually look forward to taking them."
— Sarah K.
Verified Buyer
My Honest Recommendation (No BS)
Look, I have zero financial relationship with Old School Labs.
I bought their gummies with my own money just like every other brand I tested.
But after months of research and thousands of dollars in lab testing, they're the only brand I'd stake my reputation on.
Here's my challenge to you:
Try Old School Labs for 30-90 days. Track your lifts. Notice how you never forget to take them. Feel the difference in your workouts.
If you don't see measurable improvements in strength, recovery, and consistency - get your money back. They guarantee it.
But here's what I predict will actually happen:
Week 1:
"Holy shit, these actually taste like candy"
Week 2-3:
"I haven't missed a single day - that's never happened before"
Week 4-6:
"My bench/squat/deadlift is climbing faster than ever"
Month 3+:
"Why did I waste years suffering through chalky powders?"
Get Old School Labs Creatine Gummies (90-Day Guarantee)
#2: Create Wellness Core Creatine Gummies
Third Party Potency Results (NOW) : 3.83g creatine per serving (claimed 4.5g)
Personal Taste Score: 8/10
Value Score: 6/10
The good: Great flavor
The bad: inaccurate label claims + expensive compared to value.
#3: Con-Cret Creatine Gummies
Third Party Potency Results (NOW): 0.085g creatine per serving (claimed 0.75g)
Personal Taste Score: 8/10
Value Score: 2/10
The good: Premium ingredients, good taste
The bad: Severely underdosed and expensive for value.
#4: Beast Bites Creatine Gummies
Third Party Potency Results (NOW): 0.043g creatine per serving (claimed 5g)
Personal Taste Score: 9/10
Value Score: 0/10
The good: Tastes amazing (Mostly because there’s barely any creatine in it)
The bad: Pretty much 0 creatine in it. Need to take 575 gummies to get the necessary dosage…
#5: Astro Labs Creatine Gummies
Third Party Potency Results (NOW): 0g creatine per serving (claimed 5g)
Personal Taste Score: 6/10
Value Score: 0/10
The good: Tastes sort of good…
The bad: No creatine whatsoever. Good for a movie snack rather than a gym supplement.
The Bottom Line: Stop Wasting Money on Fake "Supplements"
After months of testing and thousands of dollars spent on lab analysis, the results are crystal clear:
89% of creatine gummy brands are complete scams.
You've been paying premium prices for candy. No wonder you're not seeing gains.
But here's the good news: You now know the truth.
You know about the "clear gummy test."
You know why most brands taste "too good to be true."
And you know there's exactly ONE brand that delivers what it promises.
Your Next Move Determines Your Next 6 Months
You have two choices right now:
Choice #1: Keep taking your current gummies and hope for different results. Waste another $200+ over the next 6 months on fake supplements while your lifts stay flat.
Choice #2: Make the switch to Old School Labs and finally experience what real creatine can do for your strength, muscle growth, and recovery.
Why I'm Staking My Reputation on This
I didn't have to publish this research. I could have kept quiet and avoided making enemies in the supplement industry.
But after seeing how badly companies are ripping off hardworking people like you, I couldn't stay silent.
Your gains matter. Your money matters. Your time matters.
And if a supplement company can't be honest about something as basic as how much creatine is in their product, they don't deserve your business.
The Simple Truth
Real creatine changes everything. And Old School Labs is the only gummy brand that delivers it.
If you're not completely satisfied with your results after 90 days, get every penny back. But I'm confident you'll experience what thousands of others already have.
Get Old School Labs Creatine Gummies (90-Day Guarantee)
Stop letting supplement companies steal your gains. Make the switch today.